I found a
website where CD's are zapped in a microwave oven. The results are kind of beautiful and interesting.
Generally, I try not to think about what is art and what isn't. I don't think it is my place to say, I am allowed to decide what I like and don't like. This is different, you take a mass produced object and use a tool without any skill to change it, I don't think this is art.
I know a woman who takes pieces of metal and uses a machine to stamp patterns (with great skill) on them, that is art I'm sure. I have seen machines where put in a penny and 3 quarters, turn the crank and a penny is squished into a shape, that is not art. Clearly zapping CD's is different than
pottery that you make and put into fire to have a unique effect in the glazing.
Is an meteor you find on the ground art? No one manipulated it, so maybe it is an interesting object? I don't think a meteor is art.
What do you think, are zapped CD's art or not?